Accountant vs. Financial Planner: Who Do You Need?

Accountant vs. Financial Planner: Who Do You Need?

Accountant vs. Financial Planner: Who Do You Need?

If you are making an important financial decision, it is not always obvious who you should ask for help. Do you need an accountant? A financial planner? Or both?

Tax and financial planning frequently overlap, but they are not the same thing. As a general rule, an accountant focuses more on the tax consequences of a decision, while a financial planner considers how that decision fits with your broader finances and goals. Understanding the difference can help you get the right advice and avoid looking at an important decision too narrowly.

What Does an Accountant Do?

An accountant generally approaches a financial decision through a tax filing lens. Their work may include preparing personal or corporate tax returns and planning for the tax consequences of financial decisions.

The questions they help answer often include:

  • What tax will result from this decision?
  • Is there a more tax-efficient way to structure it?
  • What needs to be reported or filed?

An incorporated business owner, for example, may want to compare salary and dividends. A retiree may want to understand the tax consequences of a large registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) withdrawal. Someone selling an investment property may want to estimate the resulting capital gain.

Those are primarily tax questions, but answering them does not necessarily determine whether the underlying financial decision is the best one.

What Does a Financial Planner Do?

A financial planner generally takes a broader view of a financial decision and considers how different choices interact over time. That may involve retirement planning, cash flow, pensions, registered accounts, investments, tax, estate planning, insurance, and financial decisions involving a business or corporation.

A financial planner may help determine when you can afford to retire, how much you can sustainably spend, when to start Canada Pension Plan (CPP) or Old Age Security (OAS), whether to prioritize your RRSP or mortgage, or how to coordinate withdrawals from several accounts during retirement.

Tax may have a significant impact on all of those decisions, but it is usually one consideration among many financial, retirement, investment, and estate planning factors.

A Good Tax Decision Is Not Always the Best Financial Decision

Minimizing tax, especially in a single year, should rarely be the only objective.

Consider a retiree with a large RRSP. Leaving the RRSP untouched for as long as possible may defer income tax and minimize this year’s tax bill. But that does not necessarily make it the best long-term strategy.

Taking some RRSP withdrawals earlier could, depending on the circumstances, result in income being taxed at lower rates over time, reduce future minimum RRIF withdrawals, preserve tax-free savings account (TFSA) assets, or reduce the tax ultimately payable by an estate. The appropriate strategy depends on much more than this year's tax bill.

A tax professional can help quantify the tax consequences. A financial planner can consider those consequences alongside retirement spending, investment assets, government benefits, estate objectives, and other financial priorities.

This is one example of where retirement tax planning and retirement financial planning can overlap without being the same service.

Business Owners Often Need Both

The overlap can be particularly significant for incorporated business owners.

Suppose you own a corporation with accumulated savings and investments and are starting to think about retirement. There may be tax questions involving salary versus dividends, withdrawing corporate savings, paying capital dividends, selling investments, selling the business, or winding up the corporation.

The questions often extend beyond tax. A business owner may need to determine whether accumulated corporate and personal assets are sufficient to fund retirement, how those assets should be coordinated, whether money should remain inside the corporation or be withdrawn over time, and when government benefits should begin.

Those decisions cannot always be optimized by looking only at the corporation's tax return.

Similarly, someone preparing to sell a business may need tax advice well before a transaction takes place. After the sale, the focus may shift to investing the proceeds, generating retirement income, estate planning, and determining how much the former owner can afford to spend.

For incorporated professionals and owner-managers, business owner financial planning can help bring the corporate and personal sides of these decisions together.

What About Estate Planning?

Estate planning is another area where several professionals may be involved.

An accountant can help estimate taxes that could arise on death and identify tax issues involving registered accounts, investments, corporations, trusts, and other assets.

A financial planner can look at the broader financial implications, including estate liquidity, beneficiary designations, insurance needs, charitable intentions, and how the estate plan fits with the client's financial plan during their lifetime.

A lawyer may also be required to prepare wills, powers of attorney and other legal documents.

Good estate planning may therefore involve tax, financial, and legal advice rather than relying on any one professional to address every issue.

Should You See an Accountant or Financial Planner First?

If you need to prepare a tax return or determine the tax consequences of a specific transaction, a tax professional is generally the logical place to start.

If your question is broader, like whether you can retire, what you can afford to spend, how several financial choices compare, or how to coordinate your assets over many years, a financial planner may be the better starting point.

For retirees, incorporated business owners, and others making decisions with significant tax and long-term financial implications, both perspectives may be valuable.

What Is an Advice-Only Financial Planner?

Financial planners can work under different business models. Some also manage investments or sell financial products. Others provide financial planning separately from investment management or product sales.

An advice-only financial planner is paid directly by the client for financial planning advice rather than being compensated for selling investments or insurance. This allows clients to obtain advice-only financial planning without necessarily transferring their investments or purchasing a financial product.

How Tax and Financial Planning Can Work Together

Objective Tax & Accounting provides tax preparation, tax planning, and accounting services. Our affiliated company, Objective Financial Partners, provides advice-only financial planning and does not sell investments or insurance products.

Some clients engage only one firm. Others need both, particularly when tax decisions affect retirement, corporate assets, estate planning, or other longer-term financial planning.

Tax planning can help identify and manage the tax consequences. Financial planning can put those consequences in the context of your longer-term financial decisions.

Need Tax or Financial Planning Help?

If you need tax preparation, accounting support, or proactive tax planning, schedule an introductory call with Objective Tax & Accounting.

If you are looking for retirement, business owner, estate, investment, or comprehensive financial planning, learn more about Objective Financial Partners' advice-only financial planning by scheduling an introductory call.

Start the Conversation

Posted in

This article is intended for educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. The strategies and information discussed may not be suitable for your individual situation or may not be up-to-date and current. Please seek guidance from a licensed professional for advice specific to your circumstances.